Mursi's pharaonic blunder throws Egypt into chaos
Dubai, November 26, 2012
By Una Galani
Mohamed Mursi's pharaonic blunder has thrown Egypt into chaos. The protests against the Islamist president's power grab to "protect the revolution" show he has misjudged civil society's craving for democratic institutions.
His authoritarian moment threatens to destroy the fragile stability that has held in the country during the two years since the popular uprising. And it puts further strains on the weak economy.
A presidential decree issued on November 22 removes judicial review of decisions Mursi takes until a new parliament is elected, which won't happen until next year. The decree also shields the Islamist-dominated constitutional assembly from a raft of legal challenges.
The push by Mursi to add judicial authority to his executive and legislative powers is a radical attempt to fix a real problem.
The judiciary needs an overhaul - it is rife with corruption, its decisions are unpredictable and it lacks a tradition of independence. But it was a major mistake on Mursi's part to think he could deal with the judges like he dealt with the military earlier this year.
The president's move has triggered the immediate expression of the frustration that has been mounting against the Muslim Brotherhood since they took over. Mursi may have been emboldened by a recent agreement with the International Monetary Fund, and his own role in brokering a ceasefire in Gaza, and may have thought that he could seize the moment.
But this counted for little as opponents of the government - but also many of its supporters - took to the streets. The stock market plunged almost 10 percent on Sunday as investors fretted over the two sides violently clashing.
More than 500 people have been injured and one person killed in clashes with the police in recent days. Mursi's supporters and opponents plan big rival demonstrations on November 27.
It is not too late for Mursi to back down and bridge the divide. The current unrest has a direct impact on the economy, as it delays the return of foreign tourists and investors.
Egypt needs a political consensus to smooth its transition. For Mursi's own sake, the voice of the minority liberal opposition must be taken into account even if it is still too divided and incoherent.
Going forward, the Brotherhood will need broad support to implement fiscal reforms, meet its optimistic deficit reduction targets, and create jobs.
The situation is dangerous but some good may still emerge from the standoff. A deal that revokes the constitutional amendment and agrees how to proceed on judicial reform would be a step forward, and provide the Brotherhood with an opportunity to reset public expectations to realistic levels.
Mursi must prove beyond doubt that he is committed to building the stable democracy that is crucial to Egypt's future prosperity. - Reuters Breakingviews
* The author is a Reuters Breakingviews columnist. The opinions expressed are her own
More Analysis, Interviews, Opinions Stories
- Arab Spring boosts demand for bulletproof cars
- Majority of SMBs in UAE, Saudi, Egypt not online
- Smugglers abandon narcotics to feed India's gold habit
- Mideast CFO optimism ‘weakens over political worries’
- Gulf states, minus Qatar, rally Egypt investment
- Frontier markets set for strong growth in 2014
- Lack of cash, monitors add to Afghan poll woes
- EU firms size up Iran's post-deal potential
- Iran deal sparks hunt for vintage plane parts
- With new air zone, China tests US